I'll go off the radar with Paul McBeth. ** -- GoobyPls 01/10/2017 4:52PM
LeBron ** -- Gator Hokie 01/10/2017 07:40AM
Tonight, it's DeShaun Watson ** -- Baltimore Hokie 01/10/2017 12:35AM
The guy that won American Ninja Warrior -- MEHOKIE 01/09/2017 10:15PM
The guy he beat (from NoVA) was every bit as BA. -- Hokie CPA 01/10/2017 12:45PM
Yeah, it sucked for that other guy -- Manbearpig 01/10/2017 4:26PM
Dang; and yah; Roger that. That surely, counts. hard ass thing, too. ** -- bourbonstreet 01/10/2017 01:36AM
Lance Armstrong -- Newt 01/09/2017 9:17PM
Was ** -- Freddyburg Hokie 01/09/2017 10:06PM
[sigh] that was one of my best obscure fun pokes -- Newt 01/10/2017 1:42PM
He Hate Me ** -- bigbadbird 01/09/2017 7:48PM
Katniss Everdeen -- Major Kong 01/09/2017 6:55PM
At the moment...Hideki Matsuyama -- ShortFatHokie 01/09/2017 6:35PM
Bang! Nice push of H.Mat there. Yah; n/k, very strong. +1. ** -- bourbonstreet 01/09/2017 7:55PM
And two 3 putts yesterday ** -- bigbadbird 01/09/2017 7:54PM
That is pretty strong ** -- Brown Water 01/09/2017 7:35PM
Can't cross compare athletes from different sports, the -- 133743Hokie 01/09/2017 6:05PM
Messi ** -- VTDante 01/09/2017 5:22PM
Isn't close. Best. ** -- CPRVHokie 01/09/2017 8:58PM
Changing my answer despite recent loss: Serena. ** -- RhinoVT 01/09/2017 5:11PM
Inside (more) -- FfxStationHokie 01/09/2017 5:09PM
What was the question again? I forgot for some reason. ** -- HokieEngineer 01/09/2017 5:13PM
Messi/Rolnaldo, pick your poison. ** -- indiahokie 01/09/2017 5:08PM
But if you're choosing from 2....then there isn't 1 "Best" ** -- Late 80s Hokie 01/10/2017 08:38AM
Messi is much, much better. -- CPRVHokie 01/09/2017 9:00PM
Sid Crosby. ** -- Fatman 01/09/2017 5:01PM
Oh, you di' int! ** -- Coach McGuirk 01/09/2017 6:11PM
Remove injuries 2 of the past 3 years and it's Miggy. ** -- PhotoHokieNC 01/09/2017 4:53PM
Even in his Miggy's MVP years, Trout was better. He played a premium -- HokieEngineer 01/09/2017 5:08PM
HIt "nearly as well" as Miggy, but was "better"? IMO, Trout has a very -- PhotoHokieNC 01/09/2017 5:16PM
Not that WAR is a perfect stat, but Trout crushes Miggy in WAR. -- HWA 01/09/2017 5:30PM
Miggy and Trout have been on the fault line between traditional MVP -- PhotoHokieNC 01/09/2017 6:25PM
Give me Lebron, and I'll take my chances. If talking career, Brady. -- reestuart 01/09/2017 4:52PM
Yah; beat me to it. Brady at this age; on a blown knee=stunning. ** -- bourbonstreet 01/09/2017 4:55PM
Russell Westbrook ** -- Brown Water 01/09/2017 4:45PM
I'm not sure he's all-time, though he is on a trip-double tear. No doubt. ** -- bourbonstreet 01/09/2017 4:52PM
Wasn't that the question 😀 ** -- Brown Water 01/09/2017 6:50PM
I think Lebron is better. Before him, I thought Jordan was GOAT. Lebron is -- HokieEngineer 01/09/2017 4:51PM
Jordan was a killer. Best of all time. -- Hokieesith 01/09/2017 5:05PM
Read the question. ** -- PhotoHokieNC 01/09/2017 5:06PM
Maybe Mike Trout? His early results are really impressive. -- HokieEngineer 01/09/2017 4:40PM
I don't know why, but I think Trout's a flash in the pan. Astounding stats -- PhotoHokieNC 01/09/2017 4:54PM
5 seasons, either won MVP or voted 2nd every year. ** -- RhinoVT 01/09/2017 4:57PM
Trout is just ridiculous. Can make a good case he shoulda won MVP all five -- BB Hokie 01/09/2017 5:10PM
You can make a highly exaggerated case, but how good it is .. ? ** -- PhotoHokieNC 01/09/2017 5:22PM
"Highly exaggerated"? He finished second in the MVP voting 3 times and won -- HokieEngineer 01/10/2017 10:11AM
Just 3 of first 6 seasons with BA > .300; 157K avg.yr.; 6-yr BA = .306. -- PhotoHokieNC 01/09/2017 5:06PM
Now you're just trolling people. -- HWA 01/09/2017 5:33PM
Oh, gawd. Nobody's trolling anybody. Make it 3 of 5 yrs at -- PhotoHokieNC 01/09/2017 6:23PM
That's the thing. His bat is 2nd best part of his game. Perhaps best -- RhinoVT 01/09/2017 5:09PM
Kershaw. ** -- Chris Coleman
01/09/2017 4:36PM
Trout. ** -- RhinoVT 01/09/2017 4:38PM
Trouser trout ** -- chumley 01/09/2017 9:49PM
Yeah, you could argue that. -- Chris Coleman
01/09/2017 4:40PM
Only knock I have on Kershaw is his playoff appearances. OK but not -- RhinoVT 01/09/2017 4:54PM
I spent too much time with text. You guys just spit out one-word answers. ** -- HokieEngineer 01/09/2017 4:42PM
Engineers, sheesh. ** -- RhinoVT 01/09/2017 4:48PM
Just can't shut 'em up, can ya? ** -- PhotoHokieNC 01/09/2017 4:55PM
Gotta go Lebron; tho recently : Bo Jackson ** -- astrohokie 01/09/2017 4:35PM
Agreed on Lebron. ** -- nolanvt 01/09/2017 4:38PM
A few come to mind -- CantTameLane 01/09/2017 4:32PM
No doubt on names and past zenith. Which makes it a tough; answer. ** -- bourbonstreet 01/09/2017 4:53PM
Marciano was a baller? ** -- PhotoHokieNC 01/09/2017 4:19PM
Iñaki Goikoetxea, hands down ** -- JoesterVT 01/09/2017 4:14PM